Covid patients owe R $ 1.4 million to hospitals



Ṣo Paulo РContract with Ver̫nica Legnari, Andr̩ Luiz Lopes and Aderbal Freitas, all residents of Ṣo Paulo COVID-19 middle of March Health collapse. Desperate about the lack of vacancies in the public system, her families decided to move her to private hospitals.

This move may have been critical to the three’s survival, but it has also resulted in debts of up to 1.4 million Brazilian reals and funding that could last a decade.

Covid-19 Association for Victims and Families of Victims (AVICO BRAZIL) Legal advice in such cases. I have referred several people to the public defender’s office who were unable to find vacancies in public hospitals at the height of the crisis. They weren’t weak, because the weak would die without replacement if they had no money. They were people with more conditions, ”explains Paula Falceta, Head of AVICO BRAZIL.

“The hospital cannot let you die at the door with the option of treating you. He has the right to prosecute and file a lawsuit, ”said Elton Fernandez, a health law attorney. And if there is an opportunity to relocate the patient, do so. “

“If there is a risk of death and there are no vacancies, the state must take responsibility. But that ends with the discussion in court. It’s not a 100% guarantee, but it is possible for the judge to decide that the state will pay for this account, ”she says. Paola from Avico.

Sandro (right) owes a debt of R $ 1.4 million in connection with his father’s four-month hospital stay
1.4 million Brazilian real debt and a dirty name

on March 23and Sandro Novais Freitas began to worry about his father Aderbal Pinto Freitas, 74. The elderly had Covid-19 and an oxygen saturation of 85%.

“It happened at this high point, in this frenzy, when the hospitals were 100% full. He overcame a son’s natural despair. So I ran to Santa Casa with him. The first thing we heard there was that there were no beds in the intensive care unit, ”he says. Sandro.

They went to Hospital das Clínicas, also General, and then to Hospital Santa Paula, which is a private hospital. At this last address, Aderbal was hospitalized for four months. In the end, he was intubated, had a tracheostomy and a feeding tube … Fortunately, he was discharged from the hospital, but he still had scars and cuts all over his body.

“After what we saw, a 20 day hospital stay, we picked up the family, sold a car and tried to pay. But my father stayed four months and the debt is now R $ 1.4 million. I imagined paying around R $ 300,000 and that would be the biggest bottleneck in the world, ”said Sandro, who is unemployed and financially constrained. “My father always asked me to look for my name because it’s the only thing we have. Today I don’t have that anymore. “

Sandro went to the attorney general‘s office and gathered information and documents for them to assess his case. Santa Paula Hospital reports that out of respect for privacy and the General Data Protection Regulation (LGPD) it does not comment on any patient-related questions.

Monthly rate of 4000 BRL for 10 years

Coronavirus survivor Veronica Legnari, 47, is undergoing physiotherapy and medical follow-up care. Your path to exiting Covid-19 in the past will be long. It will take about a year for the disease to recover Multiples physically. On the flip side, the financial part will be in jeopardy for at least a decade as the father continues to fund her daughter’s 24-day hospital stay between March and April this year.

Veronica and her husband, care technician Diego Legnari, tested positive for Covid-19 on March 10. Twelve days later, the woman with bronchitis was short of breath and asked her partner for help. “My husband works in healthcare and knew he had no vacancies in Mairenque, the city where I live. So he took me to a private hospital in Sao Roque, ”he said.

And the medical center diagnosed (Veronica chose not to reveal the name of the place) an infection of 50% of the patient’s lungs. She ended up in the hospital and needed mechanical ventilation. Since there were no more vacancies in the intensive care unit, she was transferred to another ward in Koutia.

The cost of a 24-day hospital stay, including in the intensive care unit, is around R $ 300,000 – an amount that is paid for with a bank loan taken out by the father in installments of R $ 4,000 over 10 years. The independent company that makes personalized gifts receives help from friends through a campaign Standard group.

Veronica admits that her case is too complex to be legally resolved. “The problem is we weren’t in a hospital because my husband is a health worker and I already knew there weren’t any vacancies. Wherever he worked, he had to be intubated with a pill, which is a lot of torture, ”he says.

Entering 72 thousand Brazilian rials

At the beginning of this year, the organizer Leticia Gouvia met her husband Andre Luiz Lopez three times in the Mandaqui Hospital in São Paulo, a public place. A CT scan showed that 50% of the broker’s lungs were affected by Covid-19 and that oxygen saturation had reached 85%. Despite this situation, Andrei was not hospitalized.

On March 13, she decided to take her husband to São Camilo Hospital, where Andre Luiz was hospitalized for 20 days, 7 of which were intubated. “Through Sao Camilo I started fighting for a place in cross [Central de Regulação de Oferta de Serviços da Saúde] [sistema do estado de São Paulo para procura de vagas nos hospitais]’, he clarifies.

After entering the home address, Letícia creates a file kitten to help make ends meet. We were only able to make the down payment of R $ 72,000. We financed the rest directly from the hospital for five years, in installments of R $ 2,000, ”he says.

Lawyer Christian Ferreira is preparing for the operation to ask the state to compensate the couple. She said the trial would ask São Camilo not to collect this amount from the government.

Regarding care in the public network, the state health department said Andre was at the Conjunto Hospitalar do Mandaqui for two days in March. “He was looked after and kept under surveillance by a multidisciplinary team. Investigations were conducted and the patient was instructed to return to the site if necessary. The ability to pursue care in another ministry was exclusive to the family, ”he said in a note. The hospital appreciates compliance with the protocols given the report. The family referred the case to the Regional Board of Medicine (CRIMSP).

The Sao Camilo Hospital reported that the patient’s entire operation was normal.

Who pays the bill?

Those who still owe the hospital can go to court, according to Elton Fernandez, a health attorney who specializes in health. “If you have solid evidence, it is possible to file a lawsuit for an injunction. It’s easy? It is not easy. The judge will look suspicious and examine the effects on the public accounts, ”he wonders.

Civil attorney Anna Cristina Medeiros agrees that it is possible to sue the state for recovery of the amounts spent if there are no vacancies in public policy.

Documentary evidence such as medical records and emails, as well as witnesses, are vital. “I tell families that the complexity proves that admission to a general hospital was attempted and there was no vacancy because the evidence is from you. There’s no point in thinking a judge is kind, ”Elton explains.

“If you file a lawsuit to reclaim these amounts, it will go to court. Even if you win the stock, God knows when you will get paid. This is a serious problem in our judicial system.



Leave A Reply